October 2026

ORNL Report

Quantitative Assessment Methodology for Water Intrusion Detection in Wall Systems: Phase 3

By:
Palani, Hevar J; Safir, Islam M; Desjarlais, Andre O
Publication Date:
October 2026

Abstract

Water intrusion in building enclosure systems can lead to material deterioration, mold growth, corrosion, reduced service life, and costly repairs. Current water-penetration test methods, including ASTM E331, are primarily based on visual observation of water leakage and do not provide a standardized method for quantifying moisture that enters or accumulates within wall assemblies. This Phase 3 study builds on previous research conducted by Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), the Air Barrier Association of America (ABAA), Tremco, Inc., and other industry partners to further evaluate practical methods for detecting and quantifying moisture intrusion in wall systems. The objective of this phase was to evaluate the performance of handheld moisture meters, capacitance-type relative humidity (RH) sensors, and resistance-type moisture pin probes during controlled water-spray testing of wall assemblies. Two 8 ft × 8 ft steel-stud wall specimens with exterior gypsum sheathing and self-adhered water-resistive barriers (WRBs) were constructed with intentional holes to create known water entry paths. A third wall assembly with no penetration was used as a control specimen to evaluate the effect of changing laboratory conditions on sensor readings. Each test specimen was exposed to water spray in accordance with ASTM E331. The test sequence included 60 minutes of water spray without an applied pressure differential, followed by 120 minutes of water spray under a −300 Pa pressure differential. Sensors were installed beneath the WRB, on the interior surface of the gypsum sheathing, and at mid-depth within the gypsum sheathing. The test walls were continuously monitored during spraying and subsequent overnight drying. Handheld moisture-meter readings were also collected from the interior side of the wall after the initial spray period and after completion of the pressure-spray exposure. The results showed that all evaluated methods were capable of detecting moisture increases associated with water exposure. The handheld Delmhorst BD-2100 and Protimeter MMS2 moisture meters generally produced consistent trends and identified increased moisture levels after the full water-spray and pressure exposure. The two meters showed strong overall agreement. Both instruments also indicated that the wall assemblies returned to generally dry conditions after overnight drying. The embedded capacitance RH sensors provided continuous measurements of moisture conditions at the gypsum sheathing surfaces. Sensors located beneath the WRB showed rapid RH increases during water spraying, demonstrating their ability to detect moisture accumulation that may not be visible from the interior side of the wall. Sensors located on the back side of the gypsum sheathing showed the strongest responses near fully penetrating 1/8-inch holes, where water was able to pass through the WRB and gypsum sheathing under depressurization. Sensors near partially drilled 1/4-inch holes generally showed lower responses because these openings did not create direct through thickness pathways for water. The resistance type moisture pin probes produced results mostly consistent with those of the capacitance RH sensors. Pins installed near the exterior surface of the gypsum sheathing beneath the WRB showed the largest moisture increases, particularly at locations near fully penetrating holes. Mid-depth pins showed lower responses, indicating that moisture accumulation was concentrated near the exterior surface of the gypsum sheathing during the test period. The moisture pin calibration was effective over the tested RH range. The control wall remained comparatively stable throughout testing, although some sensor readings changed in response to laboratory humidity conditions. This finding emphasizes the importance of monitoring ambient temperature and RH, or using a control specimen, when interpreting embedded-sensor data. Overall, the Phase 3 results confirm that no single measurement method fully characterizes water intrusion within a wall assembly. Handheld moisture meters provide a practical approach for post-test spot measurements, while embedded capacitance RH sensors and moisture pins provide continuous information on the timing, location, severity, and drying behavior of moisture intrusion. Using capacitance RH sensors and moisture pin probes together can provide greater confidence in identifying moisture conditions and interpreting water-intrusion test results.