January 2011

ORNL Report

Medium Truck Duty Cycle Data from Real-World Driving Environments: Project Interim Report

By:
Franzese, Oscar ; Lascurain, Mary B; Capps, Gary J
Publication Date:
January 2011

Abstract

Since the early part of the 20th century, the US trucking industry has provided a safe and economical means of moving commodities across the country. At the present time, nearly 80% of the US domestic freight movement involves the use of trucks. The US Department of Energy (DOE) is spearheading a number of research efforts to improve heavy vehicle fuel efficiencies. This includes research in engine technologies (including hybrid and fuel cell technologies), lightweight materials, advanced fuels, and parasitic loss reductions. In addition, DOE is developing advanced tools and models to support heavy vehicle truck research, and is leading the 21st Century Truck Partnership whose stretch goals involve a reduction by 50% of the fuel consumption of heavy vehicles on a ton-mile basis. This Medium Truck Duty Cycle (MTDC) Project is a critical element in DOE’s vision for improved heavy vehicle energy efficiency and is unique in that there is no other national database of characteristic duty cycles for medium trucks. It involves the collection of real-world data for various situational characteristics (rural/urban, freeway/arterial, congested/free-flowing, good/bad weather, etc.) and looks at the unique nature of medium trucks’ drive cycles (stop-and-go delivery, power takeoff, idle time, short-radius trips), to provide a rich source of data that can contribute to the development of new tools for fuel efficiency and modeling, provide DOE a sound basis upon which to make technology investment decisions, and provide a national archive of real-world-based medium-truck operational data to support heavy vehicle energy efficiency research. The MTDC project involves a two-part field operational test (FOT). For the Part-1 FOT, three vehicles, each from two vocations (urban transit and dry-box delivery) were instrumented for one year of data collection. The Part-2 FOT will involve the towing/recovery and utility vocations. The vehicles participating in the MTDC project are doing so through gratis partnerships in return for early access to the results of this study. Partnerships such as these are critical to FOTs in which real-world data is being collected. In Part 1 of the project, Oak Ridge National Laboratory(ORNL) established partnerships with the H.T. Hackney Company, one of the largest wholesale distributors in the country, distributing products to 21 states; and with the Knoxville Area Transit (KAT), the City of Knoxville’s transit system, operating services across the city of Knoxville and parts of Knox co. These partnerships and agreements provided ORNL access to three Class-7 2005/2007 International day-cab tractors, model 8600, which regularly haul 28 ft pup trailers (H.T. Hackney Co) and three Class-7 2005 Optima LF-34 buses (KAT), for collection of duty cycle data. In addition, ORNL has collaborated with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to determine if there were possible synergies between this duty cycle data collection effort and FMCSA’s need to learn more about the operation and duty cycles of the second-largest fuel consuming commercial vehicle category in the US. FMCSA’s primary interest was in collecting safety data relative to the driver, carrier, and vehicle. In order to collect the duty cycle and safety-related data, ORNL developed a data acquisition and wireless communication system that was placed on each test vehicle. Each signal recorded in this FOT was collected by means of one of the instruments incorporated into each data acquisition system (DAS). Native signals were obtained directly from the vehicle’s J1939 and J1708 data buses. A VBOX II Lite collected Global Positioning System related information including speed, acceleration, and spatial location information at a rate of 5 Hz, and communicated this data via the CAN (J1939) protocol. The Air-Weigh LoadMaxx, a self-weighing system which determines the vehicle’s gross weight by means of pressure transducers and posts the weight to the vehicle’s J1939 data bus, was used to collect vehicle payload information. A cellular modem, the Raven X EVDO V4221, facilitated the communication between the eDAQ-lite (the data collection engine of the system) and the user, via the internet. The modem functioned as a wireless gateway, allowing data retrievals and system checks to be performed remotely. Also, and in partnership with FMCSA, two additional safety sensors were installed on the combination vehicles: the MGM e-Stroke brake monitoring system and the Tire SafeGuard tire pressure monitoring system. Both of these systems posted data to the J1939 data bus, enabling these signals to be read without any additional DAS interface hardware. Seventy-three signals from the different deployed sensors and available vehicle systems were collected. Because of the differences in vehicle data buses (i.e., J1939 and J1708 data buses), not all desired signals were available for both types of vehicles. The safety-related sensors (i.e., the e-stroke device by MGM Brake and the Tire SafeGuard tire pressure monitoring system) post the signals to the J1939 data bus and were read as vehicle-native sensors similar to those provided by the vehicle on-board computer. The additional sensors, including the GPS-based VBOX II Lite, the self-weighing Air-Weigh unit, and a wiper switch used to collect basic rain data, were incorporated directly into the DAS. Upon installation of the DAS, the sensors were individually monitored through a computer with a wired connection to the eDAQ-lite. When the proper operation of the installed sensors was confirmed, the cellular modem was connected and the ability to communicate with the system remotely via the internet was checked. When all systems appeared to be functioning as intended, the vehicle was released to resume normal operations. In addition, ORNL developed a data-retrieval and archiving system that accessed the vehicles automatically over the air and downloaded the information collected and residing on the on-board DAS. Each day the system e-mailed to the ORNL researchers a summary of the data downloaded from each vehicle, highlighting any sensors that showed a percentage of errors above a pre-defined threshold. Data collection began in May 2009 with the official signing of the Memoranda of Agreement taking place at a ceremony held at the ORNL National Transportation Research Center on July 7, 2009. During the one-year data collection period, the six participating vehicles logged over 95,000 miles (45,400 for the combination trucks and 49,400 for the transit buses) and consumed over 17,000 gallons of fuel (6,000 for the combination trucks and 11,300 for the transit buses), while conducting business in the East Tennessee area. For the combination trucks, the largest proportion of idling time (61%) and fuel consumed (50%) while idling correspond to idling intervals that lasted between 0 and 5 minutes, that is, traffic congestion and delays at traffic signals. This is followed by intervals of 5 to 10 minutes of idling time (25% of total idling time and 25% of total fuel consumed), and by the 15-60 minute time interval. The transit buses also spend most of their idling time (31%) in congestion and bus dwelling stops (0-5 minute idling interval) which also consumes the largest proportion of fuel spent while idling. However, as opposed to the combination trucks, the transit buses spent 26% (0% for the combination trucks) of their idling time in intervals that are larger than 4 hours consuming also about 26% of the fuel spent while idling. These large idling times were observed mostly at the parking lot while the vehicles were waiting to start a trip. For the transit buses, the percentage difference between the overall fuel efficiencies (i.e., fuel efficiencies computed taking into consideration idling times) and the moving fuel efficiencies (i.e., fuel consumed only when the vehicle was moving) was much higher (between 10 and 20 times higher) than that of the combination trucks. Some of this difference can be attributed to differences between vehicle types, but most is due to idling. While the total miles traveled by the two sets of vehicles during the year-long project was almost the same, the transit buses consumed almost 20 times more fuel than the combination trucks while idling. One very important variable affecting the fuel efficiency of any vehicle is its payload level. ORNL developed a model that predicted the trailer weight based on the tractor weight provided by the Air-Weigh device (trailers were not instrumented with this device, so no direct measurements of trailer payload were made). On the other hand, the deployed Air-Weigh devices provided weight information for the entire vehicle in the case of the transit buses. On average, the combination trucks weighted between 27,700 lbs to 29,000 lbs and the buses between 23,000 lbs and 23,800 lbs. To generate the distribution of fuel efficiency under the payload levels described above, 10-mile segments were considered for which the fuel efficiency was computed and counted as one observation. Overall, and as expected, the fuel efficiency decreases as the payload increases for the combination trucks. However, because the payload categories are very narrow and low (those combination trucks never made any trips that were above 42,000 lbs, far below the legal weight limit for Class-7 trucks), the variation of the fuel efficiency is not significant. In the case of the transit buses, the relationship between fuel efficiency and vehicle weight is not as it would be predicted (i.e., decreasing fuel efficiency with increasing payload). This is due to several factors. First, when the vehicle is empty (lowest payload) it spends a considerable amount time idling. This results in very low fuel efficiencies for this load-level category. At the other end of the spectrum, the highway routes (express routes) are the ones that carry the largest number of passengers. The buses on these routes spent very little dwelling time (there are fewer bus stops) and also encounter the least number of traffic lights. This results in fuel efficiencies that are higher than regular surface street routes (light fare) with many more stops (bus stops and traffic signals). The data collected in this project was also used to investigate the variability that may exist in duty cycles that are generated by the same vocation and that follow the same route. In order to do so, two sets of duty cycles collected from the data gathered by the transit buses were identified. The first set focused on freeway duty cycles. A 19 km segment of Westbound I-40 in Knoxville, Tennessee was selected and the corresponding duty cycles extracted from the database. The length of the 74 highway duty cycles ranged from 10.5 minutes to 27.6 minutes with an average length of 12.6 minutes and a standard deviation of 2.71 minutes. The variability of the duty cycles was measured by the ratio of the standard deviation of the distribution of duty cycle lengths over the mean of that distribution. For these 74 freeway duty cycles, this ratio was 0.214 (i.e., 2.71 minutes/12.7 minutes). A 4.9 km loop in downtown Knoxville, Tennessee was selected and the corresponding duty cycles extracted from the database. Thirty eight surface street duty cycles with the characteristics described above were selected. The length of the duty cycles ranged from 10.9 minutes to 22.8 minutes with an average length of 18.4 minutes and a standard deviation of 3.29 minutes. Computing the duty cycle variability in the same way as for the freeway duty cycles, the 38 surface street duty cycles had a ratio equal to 0.179 (i.e., 3.29 minutes/18.4 minutes). Under this variability measure, the highway duty cycles presented a higher variability than the surface street duty cycles. This higher variability in highway duty cycles is due to the effect of the variability in traffic conditions (i.e., highway congestion level). On surface-street routes, the main factors contributing to the duty cycle length are the number of bus stops and dwelling times (none of these factors are present on the highway duty cycles) with traffic congestion playing a relatively less preponderant role.