SNS Diffractometer puts the squeeze on methane hydrate cages, unraveling its high-pressure structureAgatha Bardoel
March 01, 2012
Chris Tulk, SNAP instrument scientist.
Compressed by 600,000 pounds per square inch, methane clathrate hydrate's high-pressure structure is revealed.
Imagine a robot sent out on the prowl on this energy hungry planet looking for methane, the principal component of what we call “natural gas” and probably the most abundant organic compound on earth.
Our robot would find this energy source in shale deposits, notably here on the east coast of the United States. However, the most abundant deposits of natural gas are under water on the continental shelves and in the permafrost in the Arctic region. At both poles, methane mixes with water and freezes, remaining trapped as an ice-like compound for millions of years.
Much further afield, methane, along with water and ammonia, are major constituents of Saturn’s icy moon Titan. Some scientists speculate that on Titan there is a methanological cycle similar to the hydrological cycle here on earth. Surface methane evaporates into the atmosphere, where it condenses and rains down to the surface again. NASA’s Cassini-Huygens Titan probe has been there and sampled it.
Methane is often referred to as the cleanest fossil fuel, producing far less harmful combustion products than either coal or oil. But it is Janus-faced: looking forward, it promises abundant energy for tomorrow; but looking back, historically it has an ugly history as a major source of environmental pollution. That’s because burning it produces carbon dioxide (CO2), a potent greenhouse gas.
Scientists are looking at how to sequester that CO2 by product, in an ice-like state. Such a strategy would create a carbon “energy cycle,” in which the methane resource is recovered and used and then the greenhouse gas sequestered in a form very closely related to the naturally occurring initial materials.
“What we do know right now is that when methane is taken up and released into the environment, water plays a critical role,” says Chris Tulk, lead instrument scientist for the Spallation Neutrons and Pressure Diffractometer (SNAP) at the Spallation Neutron Source (SNS).
“Whether it is in the oceans where hydrates form on continental shelves, in the icy permafrost conditions, or even as these materials decompose and release the methane into the atmosphere to contribute to the greenhouse effect, water is certainly involved in the process. This research should lead to better models of how hydrocarbons are taken up and released in the environment.”
"To develop such models, they need to understand at the molecular level the relationship between methane and water. The work builds on researchers’ discovery decades ago, that water forms cages, called clathrates, that contain "guest" molecules of methane and of many of the Noble gases.
At SNAP, a combination of a state-of-the-art instrument, clever experimental technique, and excellent samples have yielded detailed data of the phase structure of these methane hydrate clathrates at a pressure of more than 600,000 pounds per square inch.
Tthe SNAP team found that the correct occupancy for the largest cages in this beautiful structure is three methane molecules. This finding can now be used to benchmark methane and water interactions at various energy and pressure, and researchers can better characterize the hydrophobic interaction.
“We’ve done a lot of work on these clathrate compounds,” said Tulk, “and all of it was done on SNAP."
The structure H methane clathrate hydrate that is stable from about 0.9 to 2 GPa. The cages are constructed of hydrogen-bonded water molecules. There are three types of cages in the clathrate that are built from combinations of hexagons, pentagons, and squares of hydrogen-bonded water molecules. Methane molecules represented by blue spheres are guests in these cages.
“When we compress the methane clathrate hydrate, it goes through a phase change at the molecular level to a new high-pressure form known as structure H, for the hexagonal (six-sided) arrangement of water,” Tulk explained.
“As the pressure is increased and the sample becomes smaller, the overall density increases, as expected. But the water molecules rearrange themselves to form larger cages. These larger cages can now accommodate more than one methane molecule. The key question in this research was, how many methane molecules are in these larger cages, and how are they arranged?”
The SNAP instrument is perfectly suited to provide these types of structural details. “The repulsive interaction between methane and water, called the hydrophobic interaction, is poorly understood,” Tulk explained. “And the interaction between methane and methane, particularly when the molecules are nearly in contact and strongly repelling, is not well understood at all.”
Understanding how many methanes are able to fit in each cage and how the methane molecules are arranged within these cages provides insight into these interactions.
The research also assists computational simulation. There are currently no good models to predict clathrate structure. “Determining how many methane molecules are in a cage will give the computational chemistry folks something to shoot for with their hydrate models,” Tulk said.
Given these experimental results to come up with a new “potential”̶̶ i.e., a new calculation of the interaction force that exists between methane molecules and between methane and water─computational chemists can calculate the way methane interacts with water in the larger environment.
The ball is now in the hands of the theorists, who must come up with a model that correctly predicts this experimental observation. Then they can extend the model to better predict how water and hydrocarbons interact in the larger environment.
“That is the driving motivation for my research, to get a fundamental physics/chemistry perspective on these things that have such a large impact on the earth.”
This is a collaboration between the ORNL Neutron Sciences Directorate, the National Research Council of Canada, and the Carnegie Institution of Washington.
Research conducted at the Spallation Neutron Source was funded by the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Basic Energy Sciences.
Tulk, C. A., Klug, D. D., dos Santos, A. M., Karotis, G., Guthrie, M., et al, "Cage occupancies in the high pressure structure H methane hydrate: A neutron diffraction study," J. Chem. Phys. 136, 054502 (2012); DOI: 10.1063/1.3679875.