
Up To Date Research
By exploring carbon-14, researchers seek to understand what binds the nuclei of atoms.
For much of the public, the term
"carbon-14" is among the most
frequently mentioned scientific
phrases heard in the popular media. The
predictable decay of carbon-14 nuclei
has long been used as a scientific tool
for dating carbon-based materials in
fields as diverse as history and archeology,
yet the actual science involved
with describing the physical properties of
carbon-14 itself is less well understood.
When, in 1994, researchers discovered
the Chauvet Cave in southern France filled
with Stone Age artwork, carbon-14 indicated
the charcoal drawings on the cave
walls were approximately 31,000 years old.
Six years earlier, when scientists examined
the Shroud of Turin, results of carbon-14
analysis indicated the relic, a linen cloth
believed by many to have been placed over
the body of Jesus at the time of his burial,
was more likely woven in the Middle Ages,
more than a millennium later.
For the past half-century, carbon-14
has enabled scientists to dramatically
improve the dating of both the living and
inanimate elements of human history,
including skeletons, ruins or anything
that was once part of a plant or animal.
By existing in all living things and
decaying at a steady rate, carbon-14 gives
researchers the ability to determine with
reasonable accuracy the age of a long-abandoned
community, tool or other
artifact. And because, for reasons not yet
understood, carbon-14 decays far more
slowly than most isotopes in its weight
class, the process provides researchers with
the confidence to date items as far back as
60,000 years.
At ORNL a team led by David Dean
is using the unprecedented computing
power of the laboratory's petascale
supercomputer to examine the carbon-14
nucleus. The team, which includes Hai
Ah Nam of ORNL, James Vary and Pieter
Maris of Iowa State University and Petr
Navratil and Erich Ormand of Lawrence
Livermore National Laboratory, hopes
to explain carbon-14's long half-life and
advance understanding of what holds all
nuclei together.
"Carbon-14 is interesting to us because
the physics says it should decay quickly,
yet the measured half-life is much longer
than expected," explained Nam, a
physicist with ORNL's National Center for
Computational Sciences. "The existing
theoretical models used to describe light
nuclei such as lithium, with six particles,
or boron, with ten, have produced good
results. But carbon-14, also a light nucleus,
has been elusive. The models do not yield
a value that matches what we measure
experimentally, which means we are not
capturing all of the physics."
Parsing the nuclear attraction
An isotope's half-life is the time
required for one-half the atoms in a
sample to decay. For most light isotopes
the half-life is typically minutes or even
seconds. Carbon-14, with a half-life of
nearly 6,000 years, is an anomaly. A
simulation that reveals why the half-life
of this unique isotope is so long also has
the potential to illuminate the half-lives
of all isotopes, both long and short, thus
providing a better understanding of how
the observable matter in the universe is
bound together.
The task is especially challenging
because some of the precise properties
that bind an atom's nucleus are not fully
understood. Scientists have long known
that the nucleus is made up of protons and
neutrons, known generically as nucleons. More recently, they have determined that
the nucleons are made up of even smaller
particles, known as quarks and gluons,
held together by the "strong force." To
nuclear scientists, the holy grail of nuclear
physics would be represented by a theoretical
description of the properties of all
nuclei, including the stable and unstable,
mundane and exotic, large and small.
Dean and his colleagues have been
awarded an allocation of 30 million
processor hours on ORNL's supercomputer
to dissect the secrets of carbon-14 with
an application known as Many Fermion
Dynamics—nuclear, created by Vary at
Iowa State. Dean's team will be using
nearly 150,000 of the supercomputer's
more than 180,000 computing cores on the
project. The application is ready to scale to
even more cores as they become available.
The team is using an approach known
as the no-core shell model to describe the nucleus. Analogous to the atomic shell
model that predicts how many electrons
can be found at any given orbit, the
nuclear shell model defines the number
of nucleons that can be found at a given
energy level. Generally speaking, the
nucleons gather at the lowest available
energy level until the addition of more
would violate the Pauli exclusion principle,
which states that no two particles can be
in the same quantum state. At that point
nucleons occupy the next higher energy
level. The force between nucleons complicates
this picture and creates a computational
problem of enormous complexity
for researchers.
Using the power of the petascale
|

When carbon-14 decays, the nucleus emits an electron and an anti-neutrino and becomes a nitrogen-14 nucleus. (Visualization by Hai Ah Nam and Andrew Sproles)
|
The unprecedented computational
power available at Oak Ridge enables the
team to depart from other nuclear structure studies in a variety of respects. The
project is taking a microscopic look at the
nucleus, working with its smallest known
constituents. Nuclear models have been
moving in this direction for seven decades,
from the liquid drop model of Niels Bohr,
which treated the nucleus as a single
drop of nuclear fluid, to later models that
examined the protons and neutrons separately.
The ORNL team is able to probe
even deeper. Utilizing an ab initio, or first
principles, approach, they are working
from the strong-force interactions of the
quarks and gluons within each nucleon.
In addition, Dean's team has adopted a
"no-core" strategy that incorporates all 14
nucleons and includes more energy levels
in the model. The simulations also extend
beyond two-body forces, which include the
interaction of every nucleon with every
other nucleon two at a time, to incorporate
three-body forces.
"Previously we could only consider
two-nucleon interactions because the
number of combinations needed to
describe all the different interactions is
vast, even for only two particles at a time,"
Nam explained. "And while two-particle
interactions are the dominant way that
these particles interact, there are some
nuclear phenomena, like the half-life of
carbon-14, that cannot be described using
only a two-nucleon interaction, meaning
three-particle interactions or higher are
also significant.
"Our project is probing whether
these two approaches, using the ab
initio methods and the higher number of
interactions, will describe more accurately
why carbon-14 has such a long half-life
and help explain how all nuclei are put
together."
Calculations at this scale are now
possible at Oak Ridge using a supercomputer
capable of 2.3 thousand trillion
calculations a second—making it the
world's fastest scientific supercomputer.
Also critical are the machine's 362
terabytes of memory, three times more
memory than other system. Prior to the
system's installation in 2008, such a simulation
of the carbon-14 nucleus working
from its smallest known constituents would
have been unthinkable.
"These types of calculations for
carbon-14 were previously not possible
because the research required a memory-intensive
calculation," explained Nam.
"Accounting for the three-nucleon force
amounts to storing tens of trillions of
elements, or hundreds of terabytes of
information."
By making use of such extraordinary
computing power, the ORNL team
hopes to move a little closer to an understanding
of the atom's nucleus. If they are
successful, carbon-14 will become an even
bigger star in the scientific galaxy.

|